[eDebate] Results of the ADA Mail Ballot

Hall, Michael P. Debate mphall
Tue Aug 21 15:24:58 CDT 2007


All proposals on the ADA mail ballot passed.  You can find a copy of the
current ADA rules at www.liberty.edu/debate.
 
 
Following are the detailed results for each proposal:
 
 
Proposal 1:  "Constraints on the Affirmative" - Eliminates "that is a
policy option."
 
Yea:  7, Nay: 4
 
 
Proposal 2:  "Critiques" - Eliminates "initiate a," "policy" and, "The
critique must be logically consistent with all other negative arguments
raised in the round."
 
Yea:  7, Nay: 4
 
 
Proposal 3:  "Constraints During Rebuttals" - Eliminates "or new
positions."
 
Yea: 6, Nay: 5
 
 
Proposal 4:  "Judging Assignment" - Adds, "If the tournament offers
multiple divisions, the same method of judge placement must be used in
each division."
 
Yea: 9, Nay: 2
 
 
Proposal 5:  "Judging Assignment" - Eliminates "an 'A', 'B', and 'C',"
and adds "In instances where mutual preference judging is not used."
 
Yea: 9,  Nay: 2   
 
 
Proposal 6:  "Debate Teams at ADA Nationals" - Adds, "Speaker points in
forfeit situations will be averaged, but the team forfeiting is
ineligible to clear to elimination rounds if speaker points are the
determining factor for their clearing."
 
Yea: 10, Nay: 1
 
 
 
Michael P. Hall
Acting Director of Debate
Liberty University
Lynchburg, VA 24502
(434) 582-2080
 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://www.ndtceda.com/pipermail/edebate/attachments/20070821/b443b84a/attachment.htm 



More information about the Mailman mailing list