[eDebate] judging hypothetical

Ross Smith smithr
Tue Oct 30 21:05:30 CDT 2007

The negative reads a PIC and says it is unconditional. The affirmative 
wins that PICs are unfair and says it must be a voting issue since the 
neg has denied themselves the ability to advocate anything else. The 
unique disad net benefit outweighs the case without the CP. The neg says 
reject the argument, we outweigh.

Who wins?

Ross K. Smith
Director of Debate
Wake Forest University

336-251-2076 (c)
336-758-5268 (o)


More information about the Mailman mailing list