[eDebate] My first debate tournament
Mon Oct 22 15:33:57 CDT 2007
You have every right to post on here and I think your concerns are legitmate
and I would be happy to talk to you in detail about them. Certain things I
observed in the Novice division have caused me to re-think my role as a
debate judge and critic and specifically to make explict certain alterations
and revisions in my judging philosophy, especially in Novice round.
As I understand it, one purpose of this list is to air such concerns.
I didn't judge you and don't even know what school you are from, but do come
to another tournament and introduce yourself to me, I'd love to talk to you
about some of my ideas as well asabout what you can do to address some of
these concerns. I'd be happy to talk to any of your coaches to.
Personally, I share very similar concerns.
Do your self and our region a favor and don't drop out just yet.
On 10/22/07, Darren Surch <darren.surch at gmail.com> wrote:
> I probably shouldn't be posting on here since I am not an experienced
> debater and West Point was actually the very first tournament that I had
> attended and I am guessing my last one. I had fun when I was debating other
> people of my level and learning the ropes together, but in two rounds I
> debated these teams that were clearly in the wrong division, threw all this
> jargon at me that they knew I clearly did not know what it meant and for the
> most part were pounding their chest because of their superiority to my
> partner and me in this round.
> I am not sure of all the rules, but I have been involved in competitive
> athletics my entire childhood and although their are times when a team is
> clearly superior to another team, most times the winning coach will put is
> his reserves, but you will never see the varsity team playing against the JV
> or Freshman squad and usually those athletes that are superior are moved up
> to the Varsity squad because it is better for all those involved.
> I suggest you examine what is going on and if winning is really that
> important. One of my judges was very sympathetic to this and I may return
> because of him, but if I have to be thrown in to get slaughtered again,
> there is no way that I will ever come back. The community should examine
> this practice. I know the community is probably more worried about your
> open debaters, but I am hoping that our voices can be heard as well. As a
> community, you need to send a message to those teams that are doing this, I
> am not sure how, but there has to be way.
> eDebate mailing list
> eDebate at www.ndtceda.com
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Mailman