[eDebate] Novice at CEDA Nats and Josh

Eric Wendell Marlow emarlow
Tue Oct 28 21:48:41 CDT 2008

Jason is right.  And, for the record, I don't think his argument is 
elitist.  Teams competing in the "open" division of CEDA nats work hard 
all year and the idea that they could potentially have worse critic 
preferences in the first elim round seems to be a recipe for tragedy.  
We have almost moved past the days when the triples was just a crap 
shoot and it would be a shame to move back in that direction.

I love novice debate, too.  I have spent a good deal of my 18 year 
college coaching career working with exclusively novice programs.  I do 
not think we should privilege our mission of novice inclusion to the 
point of sacrificing the quality of our varsity national competition.


Jason Russell wrote:

>I would like to add a prior disclaimer to all of Josh's emails that he
>definitely does not intend to offend anyone, ever, under any 
>about anything. This should help speed up his ability to send emails, 
as if
>that is at all possible.
>When the novice elims are held matters. If they're held during the 
>or doubles (maybe even octas), Im opposed to them because the judging 
>all of the rounds, including the new division, will suffer. While this
>atrocity of a tournament is not as poorly judged as it was when Chief 
>to debate at it, it is, still, a crap shoot given that the bottom of the
>pool is so large that the range of individuals you may get in the 2 or 3
>range is less preferable than it would be at other tournaments. This 
>is, frankly, already driving many teams from participating in the
>tournament. Adding "just" 4 more rounds is adding "just" 12 more judges 
>the pool of elims, which is some serious stress on overall elim 
>where we should be striving for A-A match ups. Im not saying nix the
>division; Im saying careful placement is crucial.
>If there is a forced trade-off with open elims, I am, in fact, opposed 
>the division. I guess it's because Im an elitist sorta, but also because
>there are like 15 other novice national championships you can 
participate in
>beyond CEDA.


>eDebate mailing list
>eDebate at www.ndtceda.com

**ADDRESS CHANGE NOTICE**-The University of Central Oklahoma is
moving to a new Internet address.  This e-Mail address and web
sites are now available at uco.edu.  All e-mail addresses and web
sites will use uco.edu effective January 2, 2009.

**CONFIDENTIALITY** -This email (including any attachments) may
contain confidential, proprietary and privileged information.  Any
unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is prohibited.

More information about the Mailman mailing list