| Year | Tournament Champion | Tournament Runner-Up |
| 1981 | UCLA (Robert Hartmann and Arthur Wong) | University of California Berkeley |
| 1984 | Southwestern College (Steve Witt and Terri McCorkle) | |
| 1985 | Weber State University (Rick Whicker and Kevin Boyle) | |
| 1986 | Macalester College (Paul Benson and Molly McGinnis) | Florida State University (Carrie Crenshaw and Miguel Delao) |
| 1987 | Macalester College (Paul Benson and Molly McGinnis) | University of New Mexico (Mike Stanley and Leah Neal) |
| 1988 | Southern Illinois University (Mark West and John Lapham) | William Jewell College (David Israelite and Brad Roberts) |
| 1989 | Gonzaga University (Dave Hanson and Bill DeForeest) | Southern Illinois University (Mark West and John Lapham) |
| 1990 | University of Central Oklahoma (then Central State University) (Charles Mallard and Josh Hoe) | Missouri State University (then Southwest Missouri State University) (Eric Morris and Robert Olson) |
| 1991 | Kansas State University (David Filippi and Richard McCollum) | University of California, Los Angeles (Jon Dean and Brian Fletcher) |
| 1992 | Missouri State University (Jeffrey Jarman and TJ Wolfe) | Florida State University (Jay Connell and PJ Stakelum) |
| 1993 | Kansas State University (Jill Basinger and KJ Wall) | Emporia State University (Greg Achten and Jim Haefele) |
| 1994 | University of Missouri-Kansas City (David Kingston (Genco) and James Brian Johnston) | Kansas State University/Michigan State University (Dave Devereux and Elizabeth Repko) |
| 1995 | Michigan State University (Elizabeth Repko and Jason Trice) | Gonzaga University (Blake Dias and Ian McLoughlin) |
| 1996 | Southern Illinois University (Glen Frappier and Bill Shinn) | Fort Hays State University (Tim Carroll and Brandon Thompson) |
| 1997 | Northwestern University (Terry Johnson and Brandon Fletcher) | Michigan State University (Erik Cornellier and John Sullivan) |
| 1998 | Emory University (Stephen Heidt and Dan Fitzmier) | Emory University (Anne Marie Todd and Vic Tabak) |
| 1999 | Whitman College (Jessica Clarke and Adam Symonds) | The State University of West Georgia (Rachel Saloom and Chris Bonilla) |
| 2000 | The State University of West Georgia (Rachel Saloom and Sarah Holbrook) | Michigan State University (Aaron Monick and Steve Donald) |
| 2001 | The State University of West Georgia (Rashad Evans and Sarah Holbrook) | Emory University (John Rains and Kacey Wolmer) |
| 2002 | Fort Hays State University (Joe Ramsey and Jason Regnier) | Michigan State University (Calum Matheson and Austin Carson) |
| 2003 | New York University (Richard Garner and Nate Gorelick) | Whitman College (Thad Blank and Charles Olney) |
| 2004 | Emory University (Mike Beckley and Henry Liu) | University of North Texas (Nirav Patel and John Prieur) |
| 2005 | UC Berkeley (Craig Wickersham and Stacey Nathan) | Dartmouth (Brian Smith and Kathryn Clark) |
| 2006 | Harvard (Michael Klinger and Nikhil Mirchandani) | Dartmouth (Brian Smith and Kathryn Clark) |
| 2007 | University of Oklahoma (Conor Cleary and Blake Johnson) | Dartmouth (Kathryn Clark and Kade Olsen) |
| 2008 | Towson University (Dayvon Love and Deven Cooper) | University of Kansas (Chris Stone and Nate Johnson) |
| 2009 | University of Oklahoma (R.J. Giglio and Nick Watts) | Towson University (Dayvon Love and Deven Cooper) |
| 2010 | University of Oklahoma (R.J. Giglio and Nick Watts) | Whitman College (Nate Cohn and Daniel Straus) |
| 2011 | Kansas State University (Beth Mendenhall and Derek Ziegler) | Towson University (Ben Crossan and Fernando Kirkman) |
| 2012 | University of Oklahoma (R.J. Giglio and Christopher Leonardi) | Whitman College (Allison Humble and Alex Zendeh) |
| 2013 | Emporia State University (Ryan Wash and Eli Smith) | University of West Georgia (Damiyr Davis and Miguel Feliciano) |
| 2014 | Towson University (Korey Johnson and Ameena Ruffin) | University of Oklahoma (Rashid Campbell and George Lee Jr.) |
| 2015 | Towson University (Troi Thomas and Kevin Whitley) | University of Kansas (Jyleesa Hampton and Quaram Robinson) |
| 2016 | University of Vermont (Khalil Lee and Taylor Brough) | Liberty University (Vida Chiri and Tim Byram) |
| 2017 | Rutgers University (Nick Nave and Devane Murphy) | University of Missouri-Kansas City (Corey Aaron and Anthony Thomas) |
| 2018 | University of Iowa (Sam Gustavson and Geordano Liriano) | University of Iowa (Coco Christophersen and Brooke Kimbrough) |
| 2019 | University of Oklahoma (Jazmine Pickens and Darius White) | University of Kansas (Azja Butler and Kenny Delph)[6] |
| 2020 | Tournament Canceled due to COVID-19 | |
| 2021 | University of Texas (Het Desai and Zachary Watts) | University of Central Oklahoma (Grant Colquitt and Zach Huffman) |
| 2022 | Wake Forest University (Asya Taylor and Dimarvin Puerto) | University of Michigan (Joshua Harrington and Azi Hormozdiari) |
| 2023 | Wake Forest University (Ana Bittner and Ari Davidson) | Wake Forest University (Tajaih Robinson & Iyana Trotman) |
